Queensland Child Protection Commission of Inquiry News and Updates

Cabinet was warned on shredding of Heiner evidence February 14, 2013 - 5:05PM
Tony Moore

Tony Moore senior reporter

Each of three submissions to cabinet in early 1990 about the possible shredding of evidence gathered during a state government inquiry in 1989 warned cabinet ministers that solicitors wanted to review the evidence, an inquiry has been told.
Ruth Matchett, who became the director-general of the Families Department in December 1989, was closely questioned on Thursday on the shredding in March 1990 of the Heiner documents.
During her evidence, Ms Matchett said she regarded the recommendation to destroy the documents as "unusual" and "controversial".
Commissioner Tim Carmody is reviewing the decision as part of his broader inquiry into actions at Queensland's youth detention centres.
"It was appropriate to draw it to cabinet's attention," counsel assisting the Carmody inquiry Michael Copley said on Thursday.
"And then if cabinet wants to destroy things that solicitors are actively seeking then that is cabinet's problem, isn't it?" Mr Copley asked Ms Matchett.
Ms Matchett said the timing of one cabinet submission in mid-February 1990 was "unfortunate".
"This was prepared and had to be submitted on the 13th [of February], and we did not get the advice - the new advice from the Crown Solicitor - until the 16th," Ms Matchett said. "And I didn't get it until the 19th [of February], which was the day that it was considered by cabinet.
"So there would have been different options had we had that legal advice earlier."
Mr Copley asked Ms Matchett what other alternatives would be possible, telling the hearing that "destruction, retention, release, or doing nothing" were all canvassed in the submission.
Ms Matchett said the need to discuss the issue with the state archivist could have been added.
The state archivist had to approve the destruction of the documents, the inquiry was told on Wednesday.
The inquiry heard on Wednesday that the state archivist was not told that solicitors were actively seeking the documents.
Mr Copley said he was not suggesting that Ms Matchett spoke to the archivist, or had a duty to speak to the archivist to relay information that solicitors were "actively interested" in the documents.
"Or that you failed to tell her a salient point, I am not suggesting that at all," Mr Copley said.
Mr Copley said Ms Matchett had done all that she could to let cabinet know that solicitors wanted to review the documents.
On February 19, 1990, Ms Matchett received a letter from then solicitor Ian Berry, now the state MP for Ipswich, telling of his law firm Rose, Berry and Jensen's "intention to commence court proceedings".
However, she agreed with Mr Copley that cabinet authorised the cabinet secretariat to liaise directly with the state archivist before documents were destroyed, not her.
"And although she was satisfied with that [the documents were not required for permanent retention], you did not yourself know what she had been told to assist her in arriving with that decision?" Mr Copley said.
"No, the decision was for the cabinet secretariat to liaise with the state archivist."Read more:

Return to the Commission of Inquiry News and Updates Index ^^^^^^



Heiner Affair News Articles

Print Media News news articles and reports >>>>>

Additional Heiner Affair Coverage

17/02/2011 Kevin Lindeberg Statement of Concern suggests fraud

22/06/2010 Statement of Concern II calls on Premier Bligh for inquiry into Heiner Affair.

22/06/2010 ASA and RMAA joint media release

Queensland Parliamentry Crime and Misconduct Committee

Other heiner affair commentary.


MP3/Video Interviews

Radio 4BC
Radio 4BC 01/10/2009
Radio 4BC 09/07/2010
Radio 2GB 30/09/2009
Radio 2GB 29/09/2009
Radio 2GB 24/06/2009
Radio 2GB 23/06/2009 Video
ABC Radio Richard Fidler Conversation Hour 17/03/2009
Brisbane radio 4BC 20/03/2009
Alan Jones radio interview with Piers Akerman.
Alan Jones radio interview with Peter Beattie
Alan Jones radio interview with former QLD union official Kevin Lindeberg

Download PDF Documents

Crime in the Community

Forde Commission of Inquiry

Inquiry into Harmonising Legal Systems

Tasmanian Parliament Joint Select Committee on Ethical Conduct

Standing Committee Legal & Constitutional Affairs

Independent Monthly

Heiner Affair Home

Queensland Child Protection Commission of Inquiry

News and updates from the Commission of Inquiry can be found in this News Section of The Heiner website.